Even More Afterthought Heels

In my post First Socks, then Heels, I discussed a bit about the how of afterthought heels, but I didn’t really address the why of them, other than to admire that ability to put them in after the rest of the sock is knit.

There’s a couple more excellent reasons to choose an afterthought heel:

  • When using patterned or self striping yarn, the pattern isn’t interrupted by a gusset or short row heel, which gives a very pleasing result.
  • You can knit your heel in a different yarn if you wish. I’ve seen many socks with a contrasting heel and toe, which allows you to stretch smaller amounts of yarn into socks.
  • An afterthought heel is easily removed and reknit so the heel, an area of wear for many people, can be replaced without having to darn or throw away the entire sock.

peasant heel

There’s several types of heels you can insert into your little tubes of stockinette. The one usually included in most afterthought heel sock patterns is the peasant heel. There’s two more heels I recently found in the Three Sets of Sock Heels pattern by Laura Neel, the host of the very informative Math4Knitters; Crafty Living podcast.

My favorite of the two was the Thumbjoint Hat Heel, which makes a nice roomy and pretty heel, which I especially like in variegated yarns.

Thumb Joint Hat Heel

The Flat Top Thumb Joint Heel, though very similar to the Peasant Heel, gives a little deeper heel, which seems to fit my foot better since it allows a little more room for a high instep.

Thumb Joint Flat Top Heel

Thumb Joint Flat Top Heel

I had no idea there was such a variety of afterthought heels! If you happen to give them a try, let me know which is your favorite…




  1. kate says

    I’ve never tried an afterthought heel sock but I’ve been wanting to. I really like the look of the thumbjoint hat heel.

  2. says

    I’ve never done this style heel, but I’ve been disappointed in the look of my self striping yarns with the other processes I’ve used. Adding this to my to try list! Thanks! I think I’m going to do the Thumb Joint Flat Top Heel first, looks great!

    • Mom says

      You’re so welcome, Melissa. I’ve really become a fan of the afterthought heels – especially for kids socks. It’s nice to have a variety to try for fit purposes.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *